October 14, 2022
By Glenn Dyer | More Articles by Glenn Dyer
Brazilian iron ore exporter Vale could be facing a period of turmoil with a new player muscling its way on to the giant’s share register – a move that may prove immensely advantageous to Australian iron ore miners BHP, Rio Tinto and Fortescue Metals.
Brazilian conglomerate Cosan SA has acquired 4.9% of Vale SA’s common shares and intends to further increase its stake in the mining company to 6.5% when it gets approval to do so.
That would make it the single largest shareholder.
Cosan is a transportation and sugar conglomerate and much smaller than Vale. It is involved in petrol and other fuels in a JV with Shell, in the growing and processing of sugar and production of ethanol, ports and transport. It is also involved in the food industry in Brazil.
The deal marks a major breakthrough in Cosan’s push out of rural-based businesses and into the much larger iron ore industry.
Vale is Brazil’s second biggest company by market value at around $US69 billion, Cosan is much smaller, worth around $US6.5 billion and the 27th biggest company in the country.
Cosan’s stake in Vale is worth roughly 17 billion reais ($US3.27 billion).
Cosan revealed it had borrowed around $US4 billion to invest in Vale.
Cosan is controlled by Brazilian billionaire Rubens Ometto. He obviously – like a lot of wealthy business people (think John Elliott and Alan Bond in Australia in the past), doesn’t want to use his own money to expand. Either that, or Cosan doesn’t have the capital to do so.
A period of instability could be ahead for Vale which in turn could impact its investment plans for iron ore and its base metals business, all of which would be of benefit to BHP, Rio and Fortescue if it happened.
In a securities filing, the firm said it made the purchase “through a subsidiary and a combination of direct investments, equity and derivative operations.”
The company will request approval from Brazil’s antitrust regulator to raise the stake to 6.5%.
Until then, Cosan “will be exposed to an additional and exclusively financial position of 1.6% of Vale’s equity through a derivative transaction that is different from the one used for the acquisition,” it said.
Following the announcement, shares in Cosan fell while Vale’s shares rose.
Cosan said the Vale acquisition is part of a strategy to diversify its portfolio and add assets in sectors where Brazil has a clear competitive advantage.
Vale is “exactly the type of company we seek to invest in, a unique global asset, active in a sector that is fundamental for Brazil and strategic for the world’s energy transition,” Luís Henrique Guimarães, chief executive officer of Cosan was quoted by Reuters as saying.
“The quality of its iron ore and base metals reserves, including nickel and copper, is essential to enable steel decarbonization and electrification.”
Cosan made its debut in the mining sector last year, when it formed a joint venture with Aura Minerals’ controlling shareholder, obtaining exploration rights for mining assets in three mineral projects in the northern Brazil state Para, near Parauapebas, where Vale also operates.
Aura Minerals is a small is a multi-national mining company that owns and operates gold and copper mines in Honduras, Brazil and Mexico. It is registered in the British Virgin Islands and its presence might see Vale drop a proposal to sell a stake in its copper and nickel mines to outside shareholders.
At the time, Cosan had also acquired the Sao Luis port company in northern Brazil for from China Communications Construction Company, with the aim of using it to transport iron ore.
Cosan’s move onto Vale’s share register came a few days after Vale revealed it had restructured its copper and nickel businesses with hints from the market that it is talking to groups about selling 20% to 25% of its copper and nickel operations (In Brazil, Canada and Indonesia) to outside groups to help finance a more rapid expansion of these ‘green metals of copper, nickel and cobalt.
US analysts wonder if the move by Cosan to grab the largest single shareholding in Vale will change that intention.
Glenn Dyer has been a finance journalist and TV producer for more than 40 years. He has worked at Maxwell Newton Publications, Queensland Newspapers, AAP, The Australian Financial Review, The Nine Network and Crikey.
The daily resource for hands-on investors. Market insights and investment ideas delivered free to your inbox.
Copyright 2020 Informed Investor Pty Ltd ABN 42 162 871 589. All rights reserved.
No portion of this website maybe reproduced, copied or in any way released without written permission.
Share Cafe is a Corporate Authorised Representative (001283561) of Sequoia Asset Management Pty Limited who holds an Australian Financial Services Licence (Number: 341506)
Terms of Service | Privacy Policy | Contact | Advertise
SMSFBrokerFinancial Adviser
Please prove you are human by selecting the Flag.
SMSFBrokerFinancial Adviser
Please prove you are human by selecting the House.
This report looks at the results of a collaborative study Antisense undertook which looked at the largest protein expression database in Long COVID-19 patients who experienced neurologic symptoms well after the primary or acute SARS-CoV-2 infection was considered over (Groups 1 & 2, with 48 subjects Group 2 comprising a single patient from a different clinical site). The symptoms and others experienced by such patients result in a highly significant amount of illness, possibly more than all primary SARS-CoV-2 infections i.e COVID-19.
SMSFBrokerFinancial Adviser
Please prove you are human by selecting the Plane.
Kazia Therapeutics (KZA) announced yesterday morning that paxalisib did not meet the threshold to move into stage 2 of the GBM AGILE clinical trial (NCT03970447). The study was an adaptive trial designed to assess the potential of new therapeutics to treat the highly aggressive brain cancer glioblastoma (GBM) in a cost-effective manner. Demonstrating efficacy in GBM is an extremely high hurdle as shown by the fact that there is only one approved drug for the disease, temozolomide, and it is only effective in 1/3 of patients.
Given the high nature of the hurdle, in our original initiating coverage report on KZA, we only gave paxalisib a small chance of returning a positive result from the overall study. That is the nature of drug development with one group estimating only 6% to 7% of new chemical entities that commence clinical trials reach launch (Dowden & Munro (2019) Nat Rev Drug Discov). The small percentage that do make it to launch, however, more than make up for the cash spent on those that don’t.
SMSFBrokerFinancial Adviser
Please prove you are human by selecting the Tree.
Terracom will report their FY2022 results in September 2022. In the last two months there have been a number of company announcements that have given us improved visibility on our earnings forecasts and valuation metrics so we have taken this opportunity to update our numbers.
With the combination of geopolitical factors in the northern hemisphere as well as disruption from other supply regions, we believe the visibility on export coal prices over the next 12 months has also improved since our March note.
SMSFBrokerFinancial Adviser
Please prove you are human by selecting the Key.
SMSFBrokerFinancial Adviser
Please prove you are human by selecting the Heart.
Lake Resources (LKE. ASX) – LKE has signed two non-binding MOU’s in the space of 10 days. Ford Company (Ford) has signed an MOU for ~25,000t/year and last week Hanwa, a Japanese commodity trader signed a MOU for up to 25,000t/year. Subject to execution, this is an amazing feat as Ford and Hanwa are prepared to enter into longer-term strategic partnerships with LKE. Commercial negotiations are still ongoing but are expected, especially if Ford & Hanwa inject new equity into LKE, to further de-risk the project financing & thus ensure LKE and Kachi are fully funded.
SMSFBrokerFinancial Adviser
Please prove you are human by selecting the Car.
TNG Ltd is an ASX-listed technology owner and developer of the world-class Mount Peake near-surface vanadiferous titanomagnetite deposit. To unlock value, TNG will concentrate ore from its central Northern Territory mine for processing through its patented TIVAN® process produce three premium quality revenue streams: hi-purity vanadium pentoxide (V2O5) for steel alloys and Vanadium Redox Flow batteries, a quality titanium pigment for paints and a premium steel input with >64%Fe iron ore fines.
SMSFBrokerFinancial Adviser
Please prove you are human by selecting the Star.
Two recent gravity surveys have considerably exceeded expectations and revealed potential for extensions to the existing MRE at Lake Throssell, plus a material growth opportunity at Lake Yeo. This reinforces the potential for a multi-decade, Tier-1 SOP production hub based around Lake Throssell.
TMG is currently completing work towards the PFS due early 2023, including drilling to start in Q3 2022, evaporation trials and permitting activities. Results from these programs will support the PFS and any future resource upgrade.
Benchmark SOP prices have risen to ~US$940/t due to recent geopolitical developments. The Oct 2021 Scoping Study assumed a SOP price of US$550/t and contained a sensitivity analysis showing every 10% increase in price drives a +$144m increase in the project NPV of $364m. The c.70% increase above the Scoping Study thus implies a project NPV of ~$1.4bn.
SMSFBrokerFinancial Adviser
Please prove you are human by selecting the Car.
Despite the lower realised oil and gas price, which fell by 5.4% and 19.7% respectively in August, Calima managed to show improvement in its key business metrics.
We expect higher production in November due to the contribution by the new Thorsby wells which will be drilled in August/September which will see Calima meet its 2021 production guidance of 4,500 boe/d.
SMSFBrokerFinancial Adviser
Please prove you are human by selecting the House.
WT Financial Group Limited (WTL) is a growing diversified financial services company, founded in 2010 and listed on the Australian Stock Exchange (ASX) in 2015. Its advice and product offerings are delivered primarily through a group of independent financial advisers operating as authorised representatives of WTL under its Wealth Today Pty Ltd (Wealth Today) and Sentry Group Pty Ltd (Sentry Group) dealer group operations. It has around 275 advisers across more than 200 financial advice practices Australia-wide. It also operates a direct-to-consumer operation under its Spring Financial Group brand.
SMSFBrokerFinancial Adviser
Please prove you are human by selecting the Truck.
In May 2021, Corporate Connect analyst Marc Sinatra published a comprehensive research report on ASX-listed biotech Immutep Ltd (ASX: IMM). So impressed was he with IMM that Corporate Connect felt it imperative that a follow-up report be released placing a valuation on the company, because the market was not seeing the vast potential of eftilagimod alpha (efti).
This follow-up report has been released today. Using comparables, after adding cash back to their EV estimate and dividing by the total number of issued shares, Corporate Connect now places the fair value of an Immutep share at $A2.20.
SMSFBrokerFinancial Adviser
Please prove you are human by selecting the House.
Phillips 66 (PSX) has entered into an agreement with NVX to acquire 77.9m new shares for US$150m (A$203m). PSX is the worlds largest producer of speciality petroleum coke a precursor for battery grade synthetic graphite anode materials found with an Enterprise Value of US$47.5Bn and assets of US$57Bn.
SMSFBrokerFinancial Adviser
Please prove you are human by selecting the Truck.
PayGroup (PYG) delivers multi-country BPO services and cloud SaaS HCM solutions, assisting companies to manage employees in multiple, complex jurisdictions. The company has many growth opportunities, including new clients, new jurisdictions, new products, partner expansion, and new revenue sources. PYG’s scalable business model allows operating leverage and with savings from in-housing third party technology, support margin expansion.
SMSFBrokerFinancial Adviser
Please prove you are human by selecting the Truck.
OpenLearning (OLL) is a higher education technology company that operates a scalable online learning platform through a software-as-a-service (SaaS) business model and provides a global marketplace of high quality courses for learners of all levels. Its primary customers are education providers based in Australia and South-East Asia (primarily Malaysia). OLL started operations in Australia in 2012 and expanded to Malaysia in 2015, Singapore in 2018, and recently also Indonesia.
SMSFBrokerFinancial Adviser
Please prove you are human by selecting the Key.