The “revelation” that former President Donald Trump supports the “termination” of the U.S. Constitution—if that’s what it takes to make him president again—is hardly worthy of the name.
Trump’s comment—which he posted to Truth Social on Saturday and vehemently denied on Monday—is a slightly more explicit rejection of constitutional constraints than he’s ventured in the past. But it’s perfectly in line with his longstanding opposition to any inviolable limits on state power when that power is in his own hands, or at least wielded for his benefit. That Trump has never cared about the Constitution is the most obvious thing in the world.
Trump’s Political Future Hinges on How, Exactly, GOP Voters Want to Own the Libs
This apathy was evident well before Trump formally entered politics. One early indicator was his disturbing affection for eminent domain, the government’s authority to take private property for public use provided it makes “just compensation” to the owner. Eminent domain is grounded in the Fifth Amendment, so the bare concept is not unconstitutional, but in 2005 the Supreme Court substantially expanded the doctrine, allowing “public use” to include private development the government happens to think is a good idea.
The potential for corruption is clear, and the deeply unpopular ruling, Kelo v. New London, remains controversial to this day—but Trump absolutely loved it. He agreed with it “100 percent,” he said on Fox News around that time, and he had the personal history to prove it. In the late 1990s, Trump tried to use eminent domain to evict an elderly widow from her home of three decades in Atlantic City. He wanted to replace her house with a limousine lot for his casino.
Thanks to the efforts of the Institute for Justice, a libertarian public interest law firm, the widow kept her home. But Trump kept something, too: his penchant for trying to bend or disregard the law when it suits him, and his transparent lack of interest in constraints on state projects and powers he finds desirable.
On both the campaign trail and as president, while insisting he is “with the Constitution 100 percent,” Trump made his anti-constitutionalism even more apparent. Though he has lately discovered a personal interest in the Fourth Amendment, in 2015, he said he “tend[s] to err on the side of security” over liberty where privacy rights and the war on terror are concerned. The same year, he talked of “look[ing] at the mosques” and implementing a national Muslim registry, two First Amendment violations.
The Unwelcome Return of Trump’s #Resistance Reply Guys
In early 2016, Trump again had gutting the First Amendment in view, this time wanting to “open up the libel laws” to infringe on the freedom of the press. That summer, he vowed to protect articles of the Constitution that do not exist. In 2017, he said constitutional checks and balances that required him to share power with Congress are a “very rough” and “archaic” system, which is “a really bad thing for the country.” That fall, he said asserting Fifth Amendment rights is proof of guilt. In 2018, he floated unilaterally ending birthright citizenship in violation of the 14th Amendment.
In 2019, Trump repeatedly claimed Article II of the Constitution gave him “the right to do whatever I want.” The same year, he argued he should be able to abuse national emergency declarations to expand his own power beyond constitutional boundaries because Democrats would do the same thing if given the chance. In 2020, he reportedly expressed interest in declaring martial law though the constitutional preconditions for it, per Ex parte Milligan (1866), had not been met. And just last month, he called for executing drug dealers after a two-hour trial modeled on communist China’s justice system, a blatant rejection of constitutional due process. By the standard of many of his Republican supporters, even Trump’s record on the Second Amendment falls short.
Surprise! The GOP Has an Even Bigger Problem With Its Activist Base Than the Democrats.
The easy explanation for this perjurious disregard for the Constitution is Trump’s self-acknowledged greed and willingness to ignore reality itself if it serves his purposes. But were I to venture a longer theory, it would be that Trump’s mindset on government is an odd and dangerous anachronism, a holdover from the pre-Enlightenment era when power accrued by inherent right of status instead of being duly apportioned by law. Trump has no use for the Constitution because his is a medieval perspective, his ideal society a world of natural hierarchy—and he, of course, is at the top, even if he has to terminate the Constitution to get there.
With all this on record, I ought to conclude with a list of concrete steps Trump’s Democratic opponents have taken over the last two years, while in control of the House, Senate, and White House, to meaningfully curtail the power of the presidency in case Trump (or anyone with a similar view of the Constitution) gains the office again. I ought to be able to end this article that way, but I can’t, because Democrats have done no such thing. They’ve found time to boost Trump’s imitators in the midterms, but robust structural limits for the executive are, as ever, too big an ask.
It’s almost like selfish disdain for the Constitution isn’t confined to Donald Trump.
Read more at The Daily Beast.
Get the Daily Beast’s biggest scoops and scandals delivered right to your inbox. Sign up now.
Stay informed and gain unlimited access to the Daily Beast’s unmatched reporting. Subscribe now.
The famed environmental activist echoed comments she made about Trump during the 2016 presidential campaign.
Since it seems unlikely that the former president will be joining either the Marvel or DC cinematic universes, it’s probably about something else.
"You know my reference," Greene told conspiracy theorist Steve Bannon on a Tuesday episode of his show "The War Room."
GettyIt wasn’t too long ago that the Kremlin declared 2022 a “year of unity” in the country, a sentiment that quickly fell apart as Vladimir Putin’s closest allies created their own circular firing squad over the country’s handling of the war against Ukraine.Now, that infighting has peaked in spectacular and hilarious fashion, as one of the Kremlin’s most rabid mouthpieces has been challenged to a duel by one of the Kremlin’s most notorious accused terrorists.The duel, of course, will not involv
The Chinese foreign ministry said on Thursday that "strong and forceful counter-measures" will be taken after accusing Britain of failing to protect Chinese staff at the Chinese consulate in Manchester during a protest in October. British police had been investigating the alleged assault on a protester who was beaten by several men after being dragged inside the grounds of the consulate during a demonstration against President Xi Jinping. "We urge the U.K. to … stop political manipulation and ensure the normal functioning of our consulate-general in the U.K.," Wang Wenbin, spokesman at the Chinese foreign ministry, said at a regular media briefing.
Rep. Jim Jordan (R-Ohio) sparred Wednesday with a former senior Trump administration health official over whether the administration issued a “gag order” amid its chaotic response in the early days of the COVID-19 pandemic. Rick Bright, the former head of a vaccines development agency within the Department of Health and Human Services, appeared at a…
Indiana has refused to legalize cannabis. Judging from Illinois' sales to out-of-state residents, the state may be missing out on millions of dollars.
Russia is calling on Ukraine to accept "realities" even as Moscow's rhetoric on the war is at odds with the situation on the ground.
Every American locked up abroad is worthy of our advocacy, writes Amanda Knox about the controversy around Brittney Griner's release
During a sudden "combat readiness check" of the Belarusian army, at least 20 tanks are being transferred to a training ground near the country's border with Poland and Lithuania. Source: Belaruski Hajun, Belarusian independent monitoring group Details: The group says that at least 20 tanks are being transferred to a training ground near the city of Grodno in the country's northwest.
Suedi Murekezi was among the dozens of Russian and Ukrainian prisoners exchanged in a Wednesday swap, Ukrainian officials said.
The former president's older daughter has said she doesn't plan to be involved in his 2024 presidential campaign.
Critics mocked the failed Donald Trump-endorsed Republican candidate for a story that sounded awfully familiar.
Merrick Garland, center, announcing on Nov. 18, 2022, that he will appoint a special counsel for the Department of Justice investigation into former President Donald Trump. Anna Moneymaker/Getty ImagesWhen Attorney General Merrick Garland appointed veteran prosecutor Jack Smith as special counsel to oversee two criminal investigations into former President Donald Trump on Nov. 18, 2022, Garland’s goal was to shield the probes from the appearance of partisanship. But in immediate and repeated att
Former President Trump sued the Pulitzer Prize board on Wednesday for defamation, arguing a statement by the group that concluded a review conducted of previous claims he’d made defamed him. Trump had threatened to file the suit for months after the board issued the allegedly defamatory statement, which announced the conclusion of two independent reviews…
Mary Trump told MSNBC that Ivanka Trump and Jared Kushner don't need the former president like they used to.
Lawyer Ty Cobb predicted the House Jan. 6 committee will vote to recommend the Justice Department prosecute Trump.
The revelations are "even crazier than the crazy we previously thought was so crazy."
California Gov. Gavin Newsom warned that the Biden administration's plans to repeal Trump-era Title 42 immigration policies could "break" his state.
Republicans are divided over whether to land a year-end spending deal, taking it off the plate of next year's divided party and potential Speaker Kevin McCarthy.