Why North Korea and Kim Jong-un Are Scrambling for U.S. Dollars – The New York Times

By Choe Sang-Hun and Pablo RoblesDec. 9, 2022
This video was filmed inside the secretive country of North Korea.
It shows an ordinary, state-run grocery store in the capital.
Inside, the shelves are stocked with products from Western brands like Procter & Gamble and Unilever, despite the country’s isolation.
Goods were paid for using
American dollars.
What you just saw is technically an illegal transaction, but it is also a sign of the desperation of North Korea’s leader, Kim Jong-un.
SEOUL — When Kim Jong-un, the leader of North Korea, ascended to power more than a decade ago, he repeated two promises that his family has made since founding the country in 1948: to strengthen the military and to improve the economy.
On the military front, Mr. Kim, 38, has delivered more than his father and grandfather who ruled before him, accelerating the country’s nuclear and missile programs.
CHINA
North
Korea
Pyongyang
Seoul
On the economic front, he has struggled, an already isolated country made more so by years of international sanctions over his nuclear program and border closures since the coronavirus pandemic.
Its trade with the outside world devastated, North Korea is scrambling for American dollars and other hard currency, not just to feed its people, but also to finance Mr. Kim’s military and economic ambitions. It is smuggling coal and stealing cryptocurrency. It is also trying to squeeze every bit of cash from the public, selling smartphones and other imported goods to the monied class, as well as collecting “loyalty” donations in exchange for political favors.
State-run stores like the one in the capital of Pyongyang are a critical piece. Customers can use American dollars to pay for international brands of instant noodles, deodorant, diapers and shampoo, while change is returned in North Korean won.
VS
Owned by
Procter &
Gamble
Dove
Owned by
Unilever
Pantene
Owned by Procter
& Gamble
Pantene
Continue
below
Japanese
brands
Nivea
German brand
Bioré
Japanese brand
Dove
Dove
Japanese
brands
Nivea
Closeup
Owned by Unilever
Gillette
Owned by Procter
& Gamble
VS
Owned by Procter
& Gamble
Pantene
Owned by Procter
& Gamble
Dove
Owned by Unilever
VS
Pantene
Continue
below
Japanese
brands
Nivea
German brand
Bioré
Japanese brand
Dove
Dove
Japanese
brands
Nivea
Closeup
Owned by Unilever
Gillette
Owned by Procter
& Gamble
Pantene
Owned by Procter
& Gamble
Dove
Owned by Unilever
VS
Owned by Procter & Gamble
Bioré
Japanese brand
Dove
Dove
VS
Pantene
Japanese
brands
Nivea
Japanese
brands
Closeup
Owned by Unilever
Nivea
German brand
Gillette
Owned by Procter & Gamble
Pantene
Owned by Procter
& Gamble
Dove
Owned by Unilever
VS
Owned by Procter & Gamble
Bioré
Japanese brand
Dove
Japanese brands
Dove
VS
Pantene
Nivea
Japanese brands
Closeup
Owned by Unilever
Nivea
German brand
Gillette
Owned by Procter & Gamble
Such transactions, and other illicit activities, have allowed Mr. Kim to keep American dollars flowing into his coffers. It has given him the means to expand the country’s arsenal and capabilities, including testing a new intercontinental ballistic missile last month.
North Korea is now firing missiles at a rapid, sometimes daily clip. Washington, Seoul and Tokyo have all warned that Mr. Kim may soon conduct a nuclear test, its first since 2017.
On April 15, 2012, Mr. Kim gathered a massive crowd in Pyongyang to deliver his first public speech as the leader of North Korea. He said he would guide the country through any obstacle or challenge toward prosperity, yet he made clear that his first priority would be to “strengthen the People’s Army in every way.”
As he has pursued his dual goals, he has used a blend of propaganda and terror, purging or executing anyone standing in his way, while presenting himself as a “people-loving” leader in state-run media. He has made the government relatively less opaque, delivering frequent speeches and making decisions through broad party meetings. Mr. Kim even apologized for his shortcomings, tossing aside the myth of a faultless, godlike leader.
But Mr. Kim also knew that a real breakthrough for his country could be achieved only through negotiations with the United States, which led the push for international sanctions. When he met Donald J. Trump in 2018, he became the first North Korean leader to hold a summit with an American president.
While North Korea has spent decades developing its weapons, Mr. Kim can take credit for the bulk of the advances. During his rule, the country became the first U.S. adversary since the Cold War to test both an intercontinental ballistic missile and what he said was a hydrogen bomb. Four of the country’s six underground nuclear tests happened under his watch.
In 2017, North Korea conducted its first successful test-launch of an ICBM, the Hwasong-15, which Mr. Kim said was capable of attacking the United States with a large nuclear warhead. Since his diplomacy with Mr. Trump collapsed, he has focused on making his arsenal more diverse and sophisticated, unveiling and then testing a host of new weapons, from a next-generation ICBM, the Hwasong-17, to nuclear-capable short-range missiles.
North Korea’s Missile Tests
In 2017, it tested two
Hwasong-14s and
one Hwasong-15.
Musudan
2016
Hwasong-12
Hwasong-14
Hwasong-15
2017
After talks with the U.S. failed,
North Korea resumed launching
missiles, then unveiled and
tested a bigger ICBM.
Hwasong-17
2022
North Korea’s Missile Tests
In 2017, it tested two
Hwasong-14s and
one Hwasong-15.
After talks with the U.S. failed,
North Korea resumed launching
missiles, then unveiled and
tested a bigger ICBM.
Hwasong-17
Hwasong-15
Hwasong-14
Hwasong-12
Musudan
2016
2017
2018
2019
2020
2021
2022
North Korea’s Missile Tests
In 2017, it tested two
Hwasong-14s and one
Hwasong-15.
After talks with the U.S. failed,
North Korea resumed launching
missiles, then unveiled and
tested a bigger ICBM.
Hwasong-17
Hwasong-15
Hwasong-14
Hwasong-12
Musudan
2016
2017
2018
2019
2020
2021
2022
At a party congress in January 2021, Mr. Kim ordered his government to build both “super-large nuclear warheads” and make “nuclear weapons smaller, lighter and tactical.” He has called for the development of hypersonic missiles, submarine-launched ICBMs, nuclear-powered submarines and spy satellites. In April, he vowed to expand his nuclear forces “at the fastest possible speed.”
Though some recent ICBM tests have failed, North Korea is believed to have enough plutonium and enriched uranium to produce 45 to 55 nuclear weapons and may have already assembled 20 to 30 warheads, according to an estimate from the Nuclear Information Project with the Federation of American Scientists.
During a congressional hearing this summer, John F. Plumb, the Pentagon’s assistant secretary of defense for space policy, confirmed that most of North Korea’s ballistic missiles had a “capacity to carry nuclear payloads.”
The country has tested a dizzying number of weapons in recent months, one of which flew farther and higher than its earlier ICBMs. But North Korea has never launched a missile on a full ICBM range of 6,000 to 9,300 miles, raising doubts that it has fully functioning nuclear warheads that can survive the violent “re-entry” into the Earth’s atmosphere and hit targets across an ocean.
So far, it has launched all its ICBMs at deliberately lofted angles, the missiles soaring high into space. Their thrust was powerful enough that if launched at normal angles, they could theoretically reach parts or the whole of the United States, according to missile experts.
The Growing Reach of
North Korea’s Missiles
EUROPE
ASIA
Delhi
HWASONG-12
2,200 miles
NORTH
KOREA
NORTH
AMERICA
PACIFIC
OCEAN
EUROPE
ASIA
NORTH
KOREA
HwAsong-14
6,400 miles
NORTH
AMERICA
PACIFIC
OCEAN
EUROPE
ASIA
NORTH
KOREA
HwAsong-15
8,000 Miles
PACIFIC
OCEAN
HwAsong-17
+9,000 Miles
The Growing Reach of
North Korea’s Missiles
Moscow
Delhi
EUROPE
ASIA
London
Urban
areas
Beijing
HWASONG-12
2,200 miles
HwAsong-14
6,400 miles
NORTH
KOREA
Tokyo
HwAsong-15
8,000 Miles
New York
NORTH
AMERICA
Vancouver
PACIFIC
OCEAN
Los Angeles
HwAsong-17
+9,000 Miles
The Growing Reach of
North Korea’s Missiles
Delhi
Moscow
EUROPE
London
ASIA
Urban
areas
Lisbon
Beijing
NORTH
SEA
HWASONG-12
2,200 miles
Seoul
ATLANTIC
OCEAN
NORTH
KOREA
Tokyo
HwAsong-14
6,400 miles
HwAsong-15
8,000 Miles
PACIFIC
OCEAN
New York
NORTH
AMERICA
Vancouver
HwAsong-17
+9,000 Miles
Los Angeles
The Growing Reach of
North Korea’s Missiles
Delhi
Moscow
EUROPE
ASIA
London
Lisbon
Urban
areas
HWASONG-12
2,200 miles
Beijing
NORTH
SEA
Seoul
ATLANTIC
OCEAN
NORTH
KOREA
HwAsong-14
6,400 miles
Tokyo
PACIFIC
OCEAN
NORTH
AMERICA
New York
HwAsong-15
8,000 Miles
Vancouver
HwAsong-17
+9,000 Miles
Mr. Kim delivered a message to Washington in 2018: “The United States needs to be clearly aware that this is not merely a threat but a reality,” he said. “The nuclear button is on my office desk all the time.”
His arsenal is not only a war deterrent to secure his regime’s safety from foreign invasion but also diplomatic leverage to win economic and other concessions. As part of his diplomacy with Mr. Trump, Mr. Kim halted nuclear and ICBM tests. But when it failed, he tried to strengthen his bargaining power by doubling down on expanding his weapons program.
Mr. Kim seems to have reached the conclusion that delivering on his promise of military strength is his best hope for economic gains, by exchanging part of his arsenal for sanctions relief. The recent torrent of missile tests, analysts say, was part of his attempt to flaunt his growing threat and bring Washington back to the negotiating table.
When he made that first speech in 2012, Mr. Kim also said he would ensure that his people would “not tighten their belts again,” a promise his father and grandfather made but failed to fulfill.
He introduced reforms that gave factories and farms more autonomy while keeping them under state ownership. He opened up more markets to supplement North Korea’s fragile ration system, which collapsed in the 1990s and contributed to a devastating famine. He vowed to weed out corruption and favoritism. He announced plans to open a host of free economic zones to attract foreign investors.
The extent of Mr. Kim’s economic drive is most clearly on display in Pyongyang, home to the loyal elite. The city has become brighter, its supermarket shelves more full of imports and domestically produced goods. Its skyline has also become dotted with tall, newly built apartment towers. Much of the change is cosmetic, many decrepit buildings coated with pastel-color paints.
2008
TAEDONG
RIVER
Pyongyang in 2008. Media Korean Studies
2016
New
Finished
New
buildings
Repainted
TAEDONG
RIVER
Pyongyang in 2016. Media Korean Studies
2008
TAEDONG
RIVER
Pyongyang in 2008. Media Korean Studies
2016
New
Finished
New
buildings
Repainted
TAEDONG
RIVER
Pyongyang in 2016. Media Korean Studies
2016
2008
New
Finished
New
buildings
Repainted
TAEDONG
RIVER
TAEDONG
RIVER
Pyongyang in 2008. Media Korean Studies
Pyongyang in 2016. Media Korean Studies
2008
2016
New
Finished
New
buildings
Repainted
TAEDONG
RIVER
TAEDONG
RIVER
Pyongyang in 2008. Media Korean Studies
Pyongyang in 2016. Media Korean Studies
While other cities remain far behind, Mr. Kim has concentrated his resources on the capital, positioning Pyongyang as a model of urban development. Under Mr. Kim, North Korea has opened a new terminal at the city’s international airport, renovated subway stations and opened new amusement parks.
Last year, Mr. Kim created several new residential districts on the outskirts of the city. He said there would be 50,000 new homes by 2025, the 80th anniversary of the party, to help alleviate housing shortages and replace the city’s older homes. Many are high-end apartments to be doled out to the elites in the hopes of maintaining their loyalty.
A Decade of Expansion in Pyongyang
Image from 2012
New structure
detected since 2018
2022
New
structures
Mirim
Airport
2022
2022
Sadong District
Project
2022
Taedong River
2022
TONGIL STREET
Phothong
Riverside
Project
2022
Taedong River
Taephyong
Area Project
N
A Decade of Expansion in Pyongyang
Image from 2012
N
New structure
detected since 2018
Taedong River
2022
New
structures
Mirim
Airport
2022
New
apartments
2022
Sadong District
Project
New
structures
2022
May Day
Stadium
Taedong River
2022
Phothong
Riverside
Project
TONGIL STREET
New
structures
Ryugyong
Hotel
Pyongyang
SOUTH
New Sci-Tech
Complex
2022
KWANGBOK STREET
New
structures
Taedong River
Taephyong
Area Project
A Decade of Expansion in Pyongyang
Image from 2012
N
New structure
detected since 2018
Taedong River
2022
New road
New
structures
Mirim
Airport
2022
New
apartments
2022
Sadong District
Project
New
structures
RYOMYONG STREET
2022
May Day
Stadium
Taedong River
New
structures
2022
Pyongyang
NORTH
Phothong
Riverside
Project
TONGIL STREET
New
structures
New
housing
New
structures
Ryugyong
Hotel
Pyongyang
SOUTH
New Sci-Tech
Complex
2022
KWANGBOK STREET
New
structures
New
apartments
Taedong River
Taephyong
Area Project
A Decade of Expansion in Pyongyang
Image from 2012
N
New structure
detected since 2018
2022
Taedong River
New road
New
structures
Mirim
Airport
2022
New
apartments
2022
Sadong District
Project
New
structures
RYOMYONG STREET
2022
May Day
Stadium
Taedong River
New
structures
2022
Pyongyang
NORTH
Phothong
Riverside
Project
TONGIL STREET
New
apartments
New
housing
New
structures
Mirae
Scientists
Street
Ryugyong
Hotel
Pyongyang
SOUTH
New Sci-Tech
Complex
2022
KWANGBOK STREET
New
structures
New
structures
Taedong River
Taephyong
Area Project
These reforms have done little to improve the country’s economic prospects.
North Korea crawled out of the catastrophic impact of the famine of the 1990s, growing an average 1.2 percent annually between 2012 and 2016, according to the South Korean statistical agency. But that was before sanctions and the pandemic.
The economy began contracting again in 2017. None of Mr. Kim’s planned economic zones have been built.
Resort towns that were being built to attract foreign tourists remain half finished or empty.
Last year, Mr. Kim warned of a potential food crisis and urged his people to prepare for tough times ahead. He has also told them to be ready to “tighten our belts” again.
To keep his promises, Mr. Kim needs cash urgently. He told Parliament in September that the government’s most important task was to solve the problem of the people’s living standards. Missile tests this year alone cost North Korea hundreds of millions of dollars, according to estimates by South Korean and American researchers.
His options are dwindling. The country’s combined trade deficit — the gap between the goods and services it imports and how much it exports — amounted to an estimated $8.3 billion between 2017 and 2021. Even factoring smuggling coal, selling fishing rights, stealing cryptocurrency and other illicit activities, the trade deficit may still amount to at least $1.9 billion, according to researchers at the Institute for National Security Strategy, a think tank affiliated with South Korea’s National Intelligence Service.
Mr. Kim’s regime is now trying aggressively to absorb as much foreign currency as possible from the public, especially from North Koreans who have accumulated such savings by smuggling goods from China.
The country has cracked down on the use of the American dollars in non-state markets, to force people to convert them into local currency. An unlicensed money-exchanger was executed for disrupting currency rates, according to South Korean intelligence officials. The government has encouraged people to deposit their dollar savings in banks, to place them under state monitoring.
To attract spenders with foreign savings, department stores are filled with imported goods, including Rolex and Tissot wristwatches, Sony and Canon digital cameras, as well as Dior and Lancôme cosmetics — all luxury items banned under U.N. sanctions.
Selling cellphones and airtime has also become a lucrative business for Mr. Kim’s regime. More than one in every five North Koreans are believed to have cellphones.
An array of cellphones, assembled in North Korea with components imported from China, is on sale and advertised on state TV. They carry pre-installed dictionaries and state propaganda but also offer apps for traffic navigation and games, including Super Mario and Angry Birds rip-offs, and even an app that promises to repel mosquitoes with sound.
Taylor Turner contributed reporting from Seoul. Additional work by Jon Huang.
Advertisement

source