LONDON – The International Monetary Fund (IMF) has warned that open-ended mutual funds which offer exposure to illiquid assets pose a systemic risk to the financial system.
In a blog post titled How Illiquid Open-Ended Funds Can Amplify Shocks and Destabilise Asset Prices, the IMF said the less frequently traded areas of the $41trn global open-ended industry have a “major potential vulnerability”, particularly in volatile markets.
Investors can sell their shares daily at a price given at the end of each trading session, however, fund managers in areas such as corporate bonds, certain emerging markets and property could take several days to trade their assets, the global body said.
This, in turn, creates a liquidity mismatch, with the price not fully reflecting the trading costs associated with the sale. As a result, the remaining investors in the fund bear the costs which could spark a further run-on asset, particularly “if market sentiment dims”.
“Pressures from these investor runs could force funds to sell assets quickly, which would further depress valuations. That, in turn, would amplify the impact of the initial shock and potentially undermine the stability of the financial system,” the IMF said.
It added this was the “likely” dynamic we saw at the start of the market turmoil triggered by the pandemic, where mutual funds were forced to sell assets after experiencing outflows of over 5% of their total net asset value.
“Consequently, assets such as corporate bonds that were held by open-end funds with less-liquid assets in their portfolios fell more sharply in value than those held by liquid funds,” it said.
“Such dislocations posed a serious risk to financial stability, which was addressed only after central banks intervened by purchasing corporate bonds and taking other actions.”
This is not the first time questions have been raised about the mutual fund structure. Following the Neil Woodford debacle in 2019, former Bank of England governor said mutual funds were “built on a lie” due to the liquidity mismatch between the offer of daily trading and the underlying holdings.
Conversely, ETFs acted as a tool of price discovery in the bond market during the coronavirus sell-off in March 2020. As liquidity vanished from the underlying market, the all-time high discounts to net asset value (NAV) were a representation of real-time prices.
The Fed announced an asset purchasing programme at the onset of the coronavirus crisis in March 2020 in a bid to restore the smooth functioning of the markets, including $8.56bn of fixed income ETFs, resulting in a massive improvement in liquidity conditions.
The IMF said the open-ended fund sector might be tested again in a period of rising interest rates and high economic uncertainty, noting a rise in bond fund outflows in recent months.
Highlighting this, high yield bond outflows total $38.8bn so far this year, according to the Bank of America (BoA).
Ioannis Angelakis, credit derivatives strategist at BoA, said: “Outflows are accelerating amid rapidly rising rates volume levels across the globe.
“With ‘risk-free’ rates ascending rapidly, investors reduce risk in fixed income world at a fast pace. As we have been saying for some time now, we struggle to see flows into high-grade and high-yield funds reversing.”
The IMF said funds should limit the frequency of redemptions or pass on the transaction cost to redeeming investors in a bid to curb the risks but added the latter option faces challenges in periods of market stress.
The body also suggested encouraging more trading through clearing houses, making bond trading more transparent, which could help boost liquidity.
[Editor’s note: This article originally appeared on ETF Stream]
Recommended Stories
Hot Reads: Infrastructure Offers Investment Opportunity
Actively Managed Funds Mostly Failing to Beat S&P 500
ETFs in Vogue Amid Volatility
Hot Reads: El-Erian on What the Fed Must Do
Permalink | © Copyright 2022 ETF.com. All rights reserved
Long term investing can be life changing when you buy and hold the truly great businesses. And we've seen some truly…
Walgreens Boots Alliance (NASDAQ: WBA) is a top pharmacy retailer. Customers can shop there, pick up prescriptions — and soon will also be able to see a doctor, with the company investing billions to launch primary-care clinics at its stores. Is this a recipe for success, and can Walgreens be an investment that makes you a millionaire?
Has famed investor Cathie Wood lost her touch? Vertex Pharmaceuticals is close to hitting a new all-time high as the drugmaker's business is firing on all cylinders. During the second quarter, Vertex Pharmaceuticals' top line jumped by 22% year over year to $2.20 billion.
Pakistan’s central bank on Friday revoked the in-principle and pilot operations approval of Tag to operate as an electronic money institution in a move that poses existential threat to the firm. State Bank of Pakistan said in an order that it is revoking Tag’s approval to operate as an electronic money institution, the permission that is required for entities to offer innovative, user-friendly and cost effective low-value digital payments instruments such as wallets, cards and contactless payments.
Wisconsin residents hold an average debt of $30,581; it's a huge drag on the economy.
It's easy to match the overall market return by buying an index fund. Active investors aim to buy stocks that vastly…
In four years, SLO County went from majority red to increasingly blue.
(Bloomberg) — A missed debt payment by the developer of Legoland Korea theme park adds to difficulties faced by the nation’s real estate market already weakened by surging interest rates.Most Read from BloombergBiden Says Putin Threats Real, Could Spark Nuclear ‘Armageddon’Kremlin Lets State Media Tell Some Truths About Putin’s Stalling WarMusk's Twitter Takeover Hits Snag Over Debt-Financing IssueNord Stream Leaks Caused by Detonations in Sign of SabotageBiden Should Hit Saudi Arabia Where It
Nearly 72% of alternative investment managers surveyed picked the U.S. as having the best investment opportunity in the next three years, according to EisnerAmper.
We screened thousands of actively managed funds to find the best in class. Here are five funds—and five runners-up—that look to have strong staying power for the next 10 to 15 years.
BTC remains range-bound as investors await the latest payrolls data on Friday. Market Wrap is CoinDesk’s daily newsletter diving into what happened in today's crypto markets.
The Russell 1000 Index is a market-capitalization-weighted index of the 1,000 largest publicly traded companies in the U.S. It represents approximately 92% of the total market capitalization (market cap) of all listed stocks in the U.S. equity market. The Federal Reserve on Oct. 21 raised short term rates another three-quarters of a point, which will further rein in the economy. In addition, some Fed officials are calling for more interest rate hikes to combat inflation.
A look at the shareholders of Investore Property Limited ( NZSE:IPL ) can tell us which group is most powerful. With…
Litigation is looming for home insurers in Florida as cash-strapped, underinsured homeowners are expected to turn to the court system to try to force payments for flood damage that the carriers say they aren’t legally obligated to cover.
(Bloomberg) — Toronto-Dominion Bank sold $1.75 billion of loss-absorbing junior securities just as all-in yields of bank bonds stabilize near their highest in more than a decade.Most Read from BloombergMusk's Twitter Takeover Hits Snag Over Debt-Financing IssueKremlin Lets State Media Tell Some Truths About Putin’s Stalling WarNord Stream Leaks Caused by Detonations in Sign of SabotageBiden Says Putin Threats Real, Could Spark Nuclear ‘Armageddon’Trump Says US Agency Packed Top-Secret Documents
California Gov. Gavin Newsom (D) announced on Thursday that his state will begin sending tax refunds of up to $1,050 to certain residents. State lawmakers approved the refunds, which vary in amount based on individuals’ 2020 tax returns, as part of California’s annual budget signed by Newsom in June to aid residents as they face…
The transition was initiated by DeFi asset advisor Monetalis and lead by digital asset bank Sygnum.
U.S.-based employers announced nearly 30,000 job cuts last month, up 68% from the year before.
Funds investing in short-term Treasury bonds may be the best ETFs for investors in today's seesawing markets.
Meta, the parent company of Facebook, has pulled internship offers from people who were set to start working at the company’s London offices next year, ending a coveted intern program as the social media and tech giant tries to cut costs. Meta CEO Mark Zuckerberg last week announced plans to cut staff, freeze hirings and…