Mark your calendar: The Asia Cup 2022 will premiere live on tapmad starting August 27th
‘Products of LSD-infected cattle not harmful’
Home
Latest
Pakistan
Business
Sci-Tech
Phones
World
Opinion
Life & Style
Sports
Blogs
Archive
Other
Govt submits reply in SC over accountability law tweaks
The government has told the Supreme Court that the conduct of NAB has “paralysed” the government machinery and contended that the country’s socioeconomic woes were caused by the top graft buster's controversial proceedings.
In a concise statement submitted to the apex court on Friday, the government’s lawyer mounted a defence of the recent amendments to the accountability laws as a three-member special bench comprising Chief Justice of Pakistan Umar Ata Bandial, Justice Ijazul Ahsan and Justice Syed Mansoor Ali Shah heard the petition filed by PTI chief Imran Khan challenging the tweaks.
Makhdoom Ali Khan, counsel for the federal government, said it was a well-known fact that the NAB’s conduct has led to “repeated contraventions of fundamental rights of citizens”. He further stressed that the watchdog has caused economic uncertainty as a result of which foreign direct investment in the country has contracted while multinational companies have been harassed.
The statement said that there was an urgent need to amend the NAO, 1999 in order to bring it in line with the judgments of the Supreme Court and also to curb misuse of authority by and the discretion of NAB.
Read more: NAB acted as 'instrument' of persecution: CJ
"Under the Constitution, it is the duty of the state to protect fundamental rights of citizens. To promote and ensure a fair and democratic dispensation."
‘Court must avoid political thicket’
Makhdoom further contended that the route suggested by the petitioner – Imran Khan – the court would risk landing itself straight into the political thicket as no “judicially manageable legal standard” could provide a way out.
He noted that the top court must resist getting embroiled in the “hotly contested political controversy”.
Raising objections on the maintainability of the petition, the statement said that Imran (as a petitioner) lacked both locus standi and bona fide, adding that amendments of similar nature were made through ordinances in the National Accountability Ordinance, 1999 during his own term as the prime minister of the country. “It is, thus, clear that this petition does not raise constitutional but political questions.”
"This honourable court has repeatedly held that it does not decide political questions. There is no controversy before the court which calls for a decision in the context of a case. For this reason along the petition is both premature and academic. This court does not decide academic questions. It also does not rule on issues which are not ripe for adjudication.”
"This petition is not maintainable. It challenges the validity of an act of parliament for its alleged repugnancy to the Injunctions of Islam. The jurisdiction to decide such questions is exclusive to the Federal Shariat Court under 203D read with Article 203G of the Constitution.”
A statute cannot be struck down on vague allegations of repugnancy to Article 2A of the Constitution and/or the Injunctions of Islam, it added.
"The petition does not articulate in clear and unambiguous terms how any of provisions of the Amendment Act is repugnant to any of the provisions of the Constitution."
It stated that it was a settled view of the apex court that every effort must be made to save an act of the parliament, adding that the top court, after exhausting all efforts, could only strike down an act of the parliament only when provisions of a statute cannot be reconciled to a provision of the Constitution. That test is not met in the petition, it argued.
The counsel in the statement further pointed out that the petition runs contrary to the principle of trichotomy of power provided in the Constitution as it sought judicial review of a legislative enactment without it having transgressed any constitutionally recognised limits.
"The petition does not raise any question of public importance with reference to enforcement of any of the fundamental rights. A statute cannot be struck down on the basis of principles of policy, Objectives Resolution, and Article 2A of the Constitution.”
"The title petition seeks to create an impression that the offence of corruption has been abolished by the Amendment Act. This is incorrect. The legislative intent is clear," the statement concluded.
COMMENTS
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.
For more information, please see our Comments FAQ
‘Siri, is that you?’ Hira Mani gets roasted for her accent in BBC interview
Updated 17 hours ago
Court issues non-bailable arrest warrants for 12 PML-N leaders
Updated Aug 19, 2022
Police conduct raids, fails to arrest PML-N leaders
Attack on Salman Rushdie ‘unjustifiable’, says Imran
Updated Aug 19, 2022
Ex-PM says anger regarding Rushdie understandable, terms attack 'terrible, sad'
Harvard University students meet PM, COAS
Updated Aug 19, 2022
COAS talked about current regional issues and Pakistan Army’s efforts to promote peace and stability, says ISPR
Rs198b discrepancy surfaces in federal accounts
Updated 18 hours ago
Govt revises last fiscal year’s budget deficit to Rs5.61trillion
Attack on Salman Rushdie ‘unjustifiable’, says Imran
Updated Aug 19, 2022
Court issues non-bailable arrest warrants for 12 PML-N leaders
Updated Aug 19, 2022
Police conduct raids, fails to arrest PML-N leaders
'Siri, is that you?' Hira Mani gets roasted for her accent in BBC interview
Updated 17 hours ago
In an attempt to explain why she would rather speak in Urdu, Hira spoke in English and it did not fare well for her
Chaos mires Faisalabad torture case proceedings as lawyers attack Sheikh Danish
Updated Aug 19, 2022
Court okays five-day physical remand of prime accused
Jameel Ahmed appointed new SBP governor
Updated Aug 19, 2022
President Alvi accords approval on PM Shehbaz’s recommendation
NAB acted as 'instrument' of persecution: CJ
Govt trying to have 'sins' forgiven through NAB amendments, says Justice Ahsan
Senate okays amendments to NAB law
Lawmakers move to further clip NAB’s powers
PAC ‘can grill Supreme Court, NAB’
NAB jurisdiction questioned in housing scam
Coalition parties demand action against Imran for ‘threatening’ woman judge, police
Receding water levels of China's Yangtze reveal ancient Buddhist statues
Imran urges ‘neutrals’ to stand with people instead of ‘thieves’
Army troops start relief operations in rain-hit areas of Sindh
FIA traces Twitter accounts involved in ‘anti-army campaign’
Kashmiris reject ‘sinister’ Indian design of registering outsiders' votes in IIOJK
Style Anatomy: Anjiya Mithani
Style 101: 9 Lines
One On One: Saadia Yasin Siddik and Miara Shaikh
سندھ حکومت نے کراچی کی تباہ حال سڑکوں کی مرمت کے لیے ڈیڑھ ارب روپے جاری کردیے
کراچی ایئرپورٹ پر لینڈنگ کے وقت دو مسافر طیارے آمنے سامنے آگئے
پی ٹی آئی کارکنان پر تشدد کرنے والے پولیس افسران کی بہتر جگہ پر تعیناتی کا انکشاف
لکی مروت میں شدت پسندوں کے ساتھ فائرنگ کے تبادلے میں اے ایس آئی شہید
مریم اورنگزیب نے شہباز گل کی ’ہشاش بشاش‘ حالت والی ویڈیو جاری کردی
شہباز گل کی صحت کے حوالے سے نیا چار رکنی میڈیکل بورڈ تشکیل
'Siri, is that you?' Hira Mani gets roasted for her accent in BBC interview
Court issues non-bailable arrest warrants for 12 PML-N leaders
Attack on Salman Rushdie ‘unjustifiable’, says Imran
Harvard University students meet PM, COAS
Rs198b discrepancy surfaces in federal accounts
Govt slaps 100% fine on goods
The power of lies
The problem with narratives
Eye in the sky — blood on the ground
A few good men
Seventy-five years on
Pakistan’s human security challenges
This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, redistributed or derived from. Unless otherwise stated, all content is copyrighted © 2022 The Express Tribune.