By Jacob Thorburn and Brittany Chain For Mailonline
|
1.1k
View
comments
Fresh questions have been raised over the accuracy of Prince Harry‘s explosive memoir after his bold claims on royal ancestry and being gifted an Xbox years before its official release were debunked.
In Spare, the duke writes of his ‘great-great-great-great-great-great grandfather’, King Henry VI who founded Eton College and died in 1471 – despite the fact Henry VI’s direct lineage ended after his son, Edward of Westminster, died as a childless teenager at the Battle of Tewkesbury.
The duke also bizarrely claimed he was gifted an Xbox by his aunt, Lady Sarah McCorquodale, for his 13th birthday in 1997 – despite the fact the best-selling device was first released in the United States four years later in 2001.
His claims about Henry VI and the Xbox gift were both rubbished by eagle-eyed readers on social media, who slammed the inaccuracy and lack of fact-checking on a project that cost a reported £16million ($20million).
Fresh questions have been asked over the accuracy of Prince Harry’s memoir after his claims on royal ancestry were debunked by historians. Pictured: Prince Harry sips tequila with The Late Show host Stephen Colbert
Historians and experts slammed the inaccuracy and lack of fact-checking for a non-fiction project that cost a reported £16million ($20million)
In Spare, the duke writes of his ‘great-great-great-great-great-great grandfather’, King Henry VI (above) who founded Eton College and died in 1471
Publishers yesterday said that the prince’s tell-all memoir has become the fastest selling non-fiction book ever.
Harry’s autobiography Spare was boosted into the record books with 400,000 hardback, e-book and audio format copies being snapped up, Transworld Penguin Random House said.
Recalling the day of his 13th birthday, Harry writes that he excitedly opened his presents to reveal he had received the games console, which he claims was bought for him by his mother shortly before her death.
While eating cake and sorbet during the celebrations, the duke says he was asked to make a wish and was thinking of his late mother when his aunt appeared clutching a box.
He writes: ‘I tore at the wrapping paper, the ribbon. I peered inside… It was an Xbox. I was pleased. I loved video games.
‘That’s the story, anyway. It’s appeared in many accounts of my life, as gospel, and I have no idea if it’s true. Pa said Mummy hurt her head, but perhaps I was the one with brain damage?’
The Xbox was Microsoft’s first foray into the world of console gaming, debuting with a global launch in March 2000 that ignited a fierce rivalry with Sony’s PlayStation 2 and Nintendo’s GameCube.
But some have given Harry the benefit of the doubt, noting it is likely he was simply referring to a different type of gaming device, like a PlayStation, which was first released in 1994.
Historians were quick to take to social media to question the accuracy of Harry’s link to Henry VI, the last of the Lancastrian dynasty.
Royal correspondent Patricia Treble pointed out the genealogical error and the fact Henry VI had no descendants after his son’s death in 1471.
Others pointed the blame for the Henry VI error at the memoir’s ghostwriter, award-winning American journalist and author J.R. Moehringer.
MailOnline has contacted the book’s publisher, Penguin Random House, for comment.
The duke claimed he was gifted an Xbox by his aunt, Lady Sarah McCorquodale, for his 13th birthday in 1997 – despite the fact the best-selling device was first released in the United States four years later in 2001 (pictured above at an unveiling by Bill Gates)
Born at Windsor Castle in 1421, Henry VI succeeded to the thrones of England and France as a child after his father Henry V and grandfather Charles VI of France died within months of one another.
The boy king who would rule over dual monarchies was crowned at the age of eight in England in 1429 and, in 1431, was also made King of France.
He later married Margaret of Anjou, the daughter of René, King of Naples, in 1445 as part of a peace agreement with France. But the king’s health took a turn for the worst in 1453 when he began to exhibit symptoms of mental illness.
The monarch, by means of a ‘sudden fright’, entered into catatonia – a state of psycho-motor immobility and behavioral abnormality.
Margaret gave birth to the couple’s only child, Edward of Lancaster, as the king remained in his catatonic state in October 1453.
The French queen emerged as a key player in the lengthy civil war as her husband remained in ill health.
After various battles led by Queen Margaret throughout the 1450s, Henry was eventually deposed by the Edward IV, the first Yorkist King of England, and imprisoned in the Tower of London.
Harry’s link to Henry VI was debunked by experts taking to social media
His reign was briefly restored after Edward IV was forced to flee in 1470.
Henry’s second rule did not last long, however, and he was deposed again following the Battle of Tewkesbury in 1471.
His only son, Edward, is believed to have been killed on the battlefield – thus ending the Lancastrian dynasty.
Henry was said to have died of melancholy shortly after, though some evidence suggests that the newly re-crowned Edward IV ordered his murder.
Henry VI’s bloodline did continue through later generations when the son of his half-brother, Henry VII, ruled as King of England between 1485 to 1509.
Prince Harry’s actual great-great-great-great-great-great grandfather was King George III, who reigned from 1760 and 1811, more than three centuries after Henry VI died.
Another claim in the memoir that was swiftly debunked related to Harry’s discussion of a first-class Air New Zealand flight from Mexico to the UK booked for Meghan’s estranged father, Thomas.
In the book, the duke writes: ‘Air New Zealand, first class, booked and paid for by Meg.
‘We told him, leave Mexico right now: A whole new level of harassment is about to rain down on you, so come to Britain. Now.’
But despite the duke’s claims, a spokesperson for Air NZ confirmed to NZHerald.com that the airline has never offered flights between Mexico and the United Kingdom.
Spare is being sold for £14, not the recommended retail price of £28, in places such as Waterstones and WH Smith as well as online at Amazon – where it has hit the coveted number one spot on their bestselling book list.
It comes as the reliability of Prince Harry’s memoir was also called into question over his telling of how he learned about the death of the Queen Mother.
The Duke of Sussex wrote in painstaking detail of a call he received while studying at Eton College telling him his great grandmother had died on March 30, 2002.
He writes: ‘At Eton, while studying, I took the call. I wish I could remember whose voice was at the other end; a courtier’s I believe. I recall that it was just before Easter, the weather bright and warm, light slanting through my window, filled with vivid colours.’
But resurfaced photographs appear to place the prince in Klosters, Switzerland, on the weekend the Queen Mother died.
Harry posed alongside his brother William and father Charles in a media call on March 29, having recently shrugged off a bout of glandular fever in time to hit the slopes.
Resurfaced photographs appear to place the prince in Klosters, Switzerland, the weekend the Queen Mother died
Harry posed alongside his brother William and father Charles in a media call on March 29, having recently shrugged off a bout of glandular fever in time to hit the slopes
The trio leaned against a rock, laughed with one another and put their arms around each other in the pictures
It was his first public appearance after admitting to smoking cannabis and drinking underage, BBC reported at the time.
Prince Harry reportedly told the gathered crowd he was on doctors orders to ‘take it easy’ on the slopes, and appeared jovial by all accounts.
The trio leaned against a rock, laughed with one another and put their arms around each other in the pictures.
Three friends from Eton were said to have accompanied the boys on the trip.
Royal commentator Richard Fitzwilliams told MailOnline: ‘It seems from the evidence, that he was undoubtedly in Klosters at when the Queen Mother died.
‘This portrait of being at Eton, ”the weather bright and warm, light slanting… vivid colours” is therefore inaccurate.’
Princes William and Harry and their father Prince Charles with The Queen Mother during celebrations to mark her 101st birthday August 4, 2001
Pictured: Prince William, his father Prince Charles and Prince Harry leave Northolt RAF airbase, west London on 31 March 2002 after reportedly cutting short their skiing holiday in the wake of the Queen Mother’s death
Prince Harry sits in a car as he and his brother, Prince William and his father, Prince Charles head for home from a skiing trip in Klosters
Mr Fitzwilliams, quoting the Queen herself, noted it is possible that ‘some recollections may vary‘, but described this as ‘a serious mistake’.
‘Errors such as this cast doubt on the veracity of other details. If you hire a ghost writer and don’t fact-check properly, this is what can happen.
‘The book is so hugely controversial that he cannot afford mistakes such as this. Much of the appeal of the prose is in the descriptive passages. However, are there other inaccuracies? A mistake like this poses this question.’
Buckingham Palace issued a statement on March 30, 2002 which read: ‘The Queen, with the greatest sadness, has asked for the following announcement to be made immediately: Her beloved mother, Queen Elizabeth, died peacefully in her sleep this afternoon.
‘Queen Elizabeth the Queen Mother had become increasingly frail in recent weeks following her bad cough and chest infection over Christmas.’
King Charles, the then Prince of Wales, issued a statement through his own spokesman later that day which revealed he was still in Klosters.
It read: ‘He [Charles] is devastated. His only wish is to get home as soon as he can.’
A jet carrying Charles and his sons reportedly arrived back in the UK the next day, having received special permission from the Queen for the trio to travel together.
The apparent inconsistency has raised concerns among fans and critics alike, who have asked whether his recollection for the remainder of the memoir are to be trusted.
In Spare, Harry himself acknowledged his memory suffered after the death of his mother.
Copies of Harry’s memoir Spare stacked at Foyles bookshop in London. Royal commentator Richard Fitzwilliams told MailOnline there are now concerns over Harry’s recollections throughout the book
The late Queen Elizabeth famously issued a withering assessment of the Sussexes’ bombshell interview with Oprah Winfrey in which they alleged someone in the fold asked what colour Archie’s skin might be.
Some 36 hours after the extraordinary interview, the Queen said she was ‘saddened by the claims’ but that ‘some recollections may vary’.
The phrase is now somewhat synonymous with the couple, and much of the criticism surrounding Harry’s latest media blitz – and the memoir itself – surrounds whether the Duke of Sussex has accurately recalled incidents.
Prince William is reportedly devastated by the allegations levelled against his family. Pictured together at the unveiling of a statue of their mother, Princess Diana in 2021
It is unclear where Harry’s relationship with his father stands following the onslaught of bombshells he has revealed this week.
Sources say King Charles is saddened by the saga but is unlikely to publicly comment on any of the points that Harry has raised.
Harry, meanwhile, has said on multiple occasions he is open to reconciliation with his family, but there are conditions.
Speaking to ITV‘s News at Ten anchor Tom Bradby, Harry said he’d be open to reconciliation and even returning to a partial royal role, on the condition he could have ‘frank’ conversations with his family which would stay private.
‘I don’t know whether they’ll be watching this [interview] or not, but, what they have to say to me and what I have to say to them will be in private, and I hope it can stay that way,’ he said, noting he doesn’t want ‘frank discussions [to] leak out’.
The comments have been labelled ironic given all the private moments Harry has shared in his memoir.
Read more about Harry’s bombshell autobiography:
Prince Harry shares VERY intimate tale about having sex with Meghan Markle at Soho House in the early days of their relationship
Harry and Meghan ‘will be invited to coronation of King Charles but are not expected to attend’
Prince Harry claims he grew up knowing he was born in case his brother needed a kidney or a blood transfusion
Published by Associated Newspapers Ltd
Part of the Daily Mail, The Mail on Sunday & Metro Media Group