Federal Reserve Chair Jerome Powell has warned that getting inflation under control will involve “some pain to households and businesses.” What kind of pain is he talking about?
So far, the pain has been plunging stock values and higher borrowing costs for homes, cars, credit-card purchases and business investments. But the toll could also include a surge in unemployment, and all the strains that go along with it—which typically harms lower-income workers most of all.
Powell won’t explicitly say the Fed is trying to put people out of work, but that’s one implied goal of its newly aggressive rate-hiking blitz. The Fed has raised short-term interest rates by 3 percentage points so far this year, and economists think it will push them up another point or two during coming months. Higher borrowing costs typically depress spending, with softer demand bringing inflation down.
The Fed thinks a flurry of rate hikes will tame inflation without choking off growth so much that it causes a recession. That would be a “soft landing.” But the Fed could be wrong. “This soft landing doesn’t add up to us,” investing giant BlackRock advised in a Sept. 26 market analysis. “We think quashing inflation that quickly … would take a recession.”
BlackRock thinks GDP would have to contract by about 2 percentage points to cut inflation as quickly as the Fed is aiming to do. That would put about 3 million Americans out of work, in BlackRock’s estimate. The unemployment rate would rise from 3.7% now to around 5.5%. That would be a moderate downturn, as recessions go. But should the Fed really throw people out of work in order to lower inflation?
The Fed has a so-called dual mandate: to maximize employment and keep prices stable. The Fed defines stable prices as an inflation rate of around 2%. With inflation currently at 8.3%, the Fed clearly has some work to do. Employment, on the other hand, is so strong that many companies still can’t find enough workers. Nobody at the Fed will come out and say it, but on its current path, the Fed is sending the message that getting prices down is more important than protecting jobs.
The Fed is hiking rates at the fastest pace since the early 1980s, because inflation is at the highest levels since then. In the spring of 1980, inflation hit 14.6%, the highest level in modern history. The Fed, under chairman Paul Volcker, raised rates by about 10 percentage points during a 12-month period from 1980 to 1981. A recession followed, with the economy losing 2.8 million jobs. Since the economy was smaller then, those lost jobs pushed the unemployment rate to 10.8%, far higher than anybody thinks the jobless rate will go if today’s Fed triggers another recession.
[Follow Rick Newman on Twitter, sign up for his newsletter or sound off.]
But that doesn’t mean a Fed-induced recession would be fine and dandy. Wharton professor Jeremy Siegel has blasted the Fed for worrying too much about inflation and not enough about how a recession could hurt ordinary workers. Tesla CEO Elon Musk, who thinks a recession is coming, tweeted that “Siegel is obviously correct.” Democratic Sen. Elizabeth Warren of Massachusetts has warned that the Fed will “slow demand by getting a lot of people fired and making families poorer.”
Powell, for his part, argues that the risk of a recession is worth tolerating because persistent inflation would cause “greater pain later on.” He’s not wrong about the nasty effects of prolonged inflation, which go way beyond the high gasoline prices that unnerved drivers during the summer. The worst may be the decline in living standards that comes as wages fail to keep up with rising prices, especially the cost of essentials. When the Fed began hiking rates in 1980, real wages, adjusted for inflation, were falling 6% year-over-year.
That’s a problem now, too. Average wages are growing 4.4%, but with inflation at 8.3%, real wages are declining by 3.9%. That’s unsustainable. What the Fed should do about that, however, gets to the whole question of what is causing inflation in the first place.
BlackRock argues that two main factors are driving prices up: a worker shortage, and a surge in demand for goods during the COVID pandemic, which still hasn’t abated. Other factors, such as the unprecedented fiscal and monetary stimulus of the last two years, are probably lesser factors. The problem, BlackRock says, is that the Fed can’t address either of those two core problems through rate hikes, or any other tool at its disposal. That leaves a recession as the de facto fix for inflation, since a recession, by definition, destroys jobs, lowers incomes and reduces demand for goods — bringing prices down.
Unemployment, obviously, can be a pernicious problem for those experiencing it. In addition to lost income, joblessness disconnects workers from the labor market, which can make it harder to find work even when the recession is over. Some jobs disappear completely during a recession, as employers take advantage of layoffs to replace workers with technology. Unemployment insurance and other types of aid help cushion the blow, but the United States has a weak safety net for jobless workers, compared with other advanced economies.
Inflation and unemployment both hit lower-income workers harder than those who are better off. Lower-income workers simply lack the cushion to absorb higher prices or comfortably ride out a bout of unemployment. Inflation hurts little-by-little over a long period of time. Unemployment hurts a lot right away, and for as long as it lasts. Choosing one form of pain over the other is a Hobson’s choice.
Even Powell has begun to hint it may take a recession, and millions of lost jobs, to lower inflation to acceptable levels. The Fed’s own prediction is for the unemployment rate rising to 4.4% during the next 12 months, which would equate with about 1.3 million lost jobs.
“We think we need to have softer labor market conditions,” Powell said, euphemistically, after the Fed’s last meeting, on Sept. 22. “We’re never going to say there are too many people working, but … people are really suffering from inflation.” And soon, from unemployment.
Rick Newman is a senior columnist for Yahoo Finance. Follow him on Twitter at @rickjnewman
Click here for politics news related to business and money
Read the latest financial and business news from Yahoo Finance
Download the Yahoo Finance app for Apple or Android
Follow Yahoo Finance on Twitter, Facebook, Instagram, Flipboard, LinkedIn, and YouTube
Reduced openings are a clear sign that the Fed’s anti-inflation strategy is taking effect — but also a potential omen of economic hardship to come.
The website of OKX, a Seychelles-registered crypto exchange, was blocked in Russia, according to Roskomsvoboda, a local NGO monitoring online censorship. Roskomsvoboda's registry of blacklisted websites says Okx.com IP addresses were blocked due to the decision of the prosecutor general office № 73/3-105-2022. The reasons for this ban are unknown and no previous public comments related to OKX has been voiced by the agency.
(Bloomberg) — US companies hired at a solid clip in September, suggesting demand for workers remains healthy despite rising economic uncertainty.Most Read from BloombergMusk Revives $44 Billion Twitter Bid, Aiming to Avoid TrialLoretta Lynn, Coal Miner's Daughter And Country Queen, DiesElon Musk Sets Off Uproar in Ukraine by Tweeting His ‘Peace’ PlanStock Shorts Fold in Best Two-Day Rally Since 2020: Markets WrapBiden, Kishida Condemn North Korean Missile Launch Over JapanBusinesses’ payrolls r
Moscow says a US decision to send more military aid to Ukraine is an "immediate threat" to Russia.
Betting odds are stacked against Truss outlasting Theresa May’s premiership.
Billionaire Barry Sternlicht, the chief executive officer and chairman of Starwood Capital Group, has jumped aboard the bandwagon of people calling on the Federal Reserve to ease off its aggressive interest-rate hikes before something, somewhere, breaks.
California has pretty much always paid much more than the nation for gasoline at the pump, in part due to higher taxes and a more expensive blend of fuel, but an average price that's nearly 70% more than just about everyone else in the U.S. is a bit extreme.
Faced with mounting evidence that loose U.S. monetary policy contributed to the breakout of inflation last year, the Federal Reserve now faces the risk it jumped too far the other way with its plans to fight price pressures through continued aggressive interest rate hikes even as the world economy wobbles. The warning signs of a policy overcorrection have intensified as the U.S. central bank's intent to "raise and hold" its benchmark overnight interest rate touched off a global asset repricing – stocks and currencies have fallen and borrowing costs for governments and corporations have risen – that some analysts worry has outpaced the Fed's ability to assess the impact of its policies. Economists at Morgan Stanley recently estimated that between inflation and stricter Fed policy, dollar liquidity in the United States, Europe, Japan and China has declined by $4 trillion since March and is falling fast.
(Bloomberg) — Federal Reserve officials are starting to get what they want from the economy, but the bar for any “pivot” toward a less-aggressive monetary policy tightening path is probably still high.Most Read from BloombergMusk Revives $44 Billion Twitter Bid, Aiming to Avoid TrialLoretta Lynn, Coal Miner's Daughter And Country Queen, DiesElon Musk Sets Off Uproar in Ukraine by Tweeting His ‘Peace’ PlanBiden, Kishida Condemn North Korean Missile Launch Over JapanStock Shorts Fold in Best Two-
(Reuters) -The largest U.S. oil trade groups said on Tuesday that they have "significant concerns" that the Biden administration is considering limiting fuel exports to lower consumer prices and urged top officials to take the option off the table, according to a letter seen by Reuters. The joint letter from the American Petroleum Institute and the American Fuel and Petrochemical Manufactures to Energy Secretary Jennifer Granholm represents the latest volley in a clash between the oil industry and the Biden administration over high energy prices. President Joe Biden has made battling an energy-led surge in consumer prices a top priority and has repeatedly chided oil companies for earning bumper profits at a time of record gasoline prices.
America’s debt problem has reached a critical point.
Amid rampant inflation, Social Security payments are set to get a hefty boost. But that boon may come with a major consequence: a gnarly tax bill. With inflation running at 8.5% after running as high as 9.1% this year compared … Continue reading → The post Will Inflation Cause 85% of Your Social Security Income to Be Taxed? appeared first on SmartAsset Blog.
New research by the International Monetary Fund shows that sustained wage-price spirals are historically rare, and recent sharp interest rate hikes by central banks are likely to help prevent high inflation expectations from becoming entrenched. In an analytical chapter released on Wednesday from the IMF's forthcoming World Economic Outlook, the Fund said wage and price hike dynamics in 2020 and 2021 were driven by "highly unusual" COVID-19 pandemic shocks, unlike past episodes that reacted to more conventional economic forces. IMF researchers studied 22 episodes of high inflation and falling real wages in advanced economies over the past 50 years and found most subsided quickly.
Former President Donald Trump on Monday sued CNN, seeking $475 million in damages, saying the network had defamed him in an effort to short-circuit any future political campaign.
Markets are set to remain choppy, according to BlackRock.
(Bloomberg) — Taiwan pledged to work closely with the US and other allies to prevent China’s military from acquiring state-of-the-art technology, as Washington steps up efforts to contain the world’s No. 2 economy. Most Read from BloombergMusk Revives $44 Billion Twitter Bid, Aiming to Avoid TrialLoretta Lynn, Coal Miner's Daughter And Country Queen, DiesElon Musk Sets Off Uproar in Ukraine by Tweeting His ‘Peace’ PlanStock Shorts Fold in Best Two-Day Rally Since 2020: Markets WrapBiden, Kishid
Musk does about-face and wants Twitter at original price, Micron will build largest-ever U.S. chip factory in New York, Warren Buffett’s heir apparent may buy more Berkshire stock, and other news to start your day.
British pound slumps to lowest level against dollar since 1971 after Kwasi Kwarteng’s mini-Budget
The semiconductor plant in Clay, N.Y., would be the largest in the U.S., as Washington tries to boost the industry.
(Bloomberg) — White House officials have asked the US Energy Department to analyze the possible impacts of a ban on exports of gasoline, diesel and other refined petroleum products, an indication that the controversial idea is gaining traction in some parts of the Biden administration.Most Read from BloombergMusk Revives $44 Billion Twitter Bid, Aiming to Avoid TrialLoretta Lynn, Coal Miner's Daughter And Country Queen, DiesElon Musk Sets Off Uproar in Ukraine by Tweeting His ‘Peace’ PlanStock