(Adds HKMA comment in paragraph 13)
By Tom Westbrook and Georgina Lee
SINGAPORE/HONG KONG, Dec 5 (Reuters) – It's what is known in the markets as a "tail risk": a highly unlikely scenario in which Hong Kong's currency peg suddenly snaps. Yet market pricing suggests bets on such a shock are building in the hedge fund world, and some traders say it makes a lot of sense.
Billionaire money manager Bill Ackman went public last month with his wager that the days of the Hong Kong dollar's 39-year-old peg to the U.S. dollar are numbered.
Ripples in the derivatives market imply he is not alone, as "macro" trading – or betting on big global shifts – swings back into vogue and the prospect of reaping a huge reward for relatively little risk revives a perennially unsuccessful trade.
Most fundamental analysts say such bets are foolish, pointing to the city's still massive reserves and China's backing.
But they can be relatively cheap and even profitable regardless of the peg staying intact, and it buys insurance against unlikely but not impossible chains of events, such as a sudden blow-up in China, devaluation or a geopolitical chill.
"For me, the Hong Kong dollar peg is like a delayed, or lagging bet against China," said Diego Parrilla, who runs Quadriga Igneo, a $240 million fund designed to profit from market turmoil.
"You are taking advantage of the extreme complacency of the market," he said. "The downside is limited to the premium spent…I'm risking very little and can make a lot."
Saba Capital founder Boaz Weinstein is also positioned for a break of the peg, and said on Twitter the payoff could be "upwards of 200-to-1".
The cost and size of these positions is unclear, but Ackman and Parrilla have said their bets are placed using options.
Options are contracts that, for an up-front fee, allow investors to bet on the movement of asset prices without the risk of losses beyond the initial fee, and there are signs that such bets are picking up.
A measure of the spread, or skew, between puts and calls in the options market has hit its widest in about three years in favour of U.S. dollar calls, suggesting bets against the Hong Kong dollar are becoming a little more crowded.
The Hong Kong dollar has been pegged in a tight band between 7.75 and 7.85 per greenback for nearly four decades. Its stability and fungibility have been major foundations for Hong Kong's success as a financial centre and a hub for money moving into and out of China.
STATUS QUO
China rarely comments on the peg, but in 2014 its cabinet said the government would "firmly support" Hong Kong in maintaining the peg and the stability of the city. The Hong Kong Monetary Authority (HKMA) says it has "no need and no intention" to change the system, and sufficient reserves to defend the peg.
The HKMA maintains the peg by moving interest rates in lockstep with the United States, and by currency intervention, which drains cash from the system and is designed to drive local rates up until inflows stabilise the currency.
Trades betting against the peg, perhaps encouraged by spectacular examples of broken pegs in the past in places such as Switzerland or Argentina, seem to resurface every time U.S. interest rates go up, and investors' reasoning varies.
One possible outcome, rather than a clean break, is a re-pegging from dollars to China's yuan currency.
Yet Chinese and Hong Kong officials have never given any inkling that change is being considered, and analysts do not think the discomfort outweighs the peg's usefulness.
"As long as capital controls still remain in China…Hong Kong still provides a good window for the inflow and outflow of money," said Redmond Wong, Greater China strategist at Saxo Markets. "I don't see why there is any immediate trigger … to change the status quo."
OPTIONS OPEN
Even wrong bets on the peg breaking can be profitable, and protected by the peg itself.
If, rather than options, traders bet against the peg using forwards – another contract where parties agree to trade currencies in the future – the position can earn money if the Hong Kong dollar doesn't rise. Losses would also be capped by the strong end of the currency band.
In the short-term, the market is moving against this style of trade as local interest rates and the Hong Kong dollar go up.
But some investors still see value in longer-dated contracts. A one-year forward can stay profitable if spot prices are weaker than about 7.78 per dollar, where the currency traded on Friday, in a year's time.
"The far forwards market still prices in higher U.S. rates than Hong Kong rates," said Mukesh Dave, founder and CIO at Aravali Asset Management in Singapore, which in theory ought to contain gains in the Hong Kong dollar.
The cost of notional $1 million one-year U.S. dollar call option with a strike price of HK$7.95, for comparison, is about 55 basis points or $5,500, according to Dave.
Although costlier up front, and without the prospect of profit if the peg remains, bettors seem to be preferring the options route and say it offers a better risk-reward.
John Floyd, who runs his own hedge fund from New Jersey and recommended options to short the yuan and Hong Kong dollar in February, said a forwards position is dangerously exposed should China end the peg with a conversion to yuan at a price stronger than the currency band.
"The only way to express this trade that both controls downside risk and allows for the upside profit … is through outright long option exposure." (Additional reporting by Vidya Ranganathan in Singapore. Editing by Kim Coghill)
Related Quotes
For the third consecutive week, the weekend promises to be decisive for the banking sector, as investors fear that Silicon Valley Bank's difficulties will spread. On March 10 regulators had to shut down the bank, resulting in the second-biggest bank failure in American history, after the collapse of Washington Mutual in the financial crisis of 2008. The crisis also reached Europe, pushing the Swiss government to force UBS to urgently buy its compatriot Credit Suisse for the modest sum of $3.24 billion.
Experts say investors may be able to generate attractive, short-term returns as the Fed continues to raise rates
They allege they were not given notice before their personal belongings were auctioned off.
"When people are like, 'Oh California is so much more expensive than Texas,' that’s the top income tax rate."
Since the banking crisis began, investors have been looking toward the Federal Reserve. The central bank’s move on interest rates had been widely anticipated, and investors were eager for a sign to indicate whether the Fed saw inflation or a bank run crisis as the greater threat. With central bank’s announcement of a 25 basis point rate hike, or 0.25%, the impression is that the Fed has tried to take a middle path, and is slowing its interest rate policy to calm the banking sector while not aban
Total household balances in retirement accounts for those 55 to 64 years old are $413,814 on average, according to its estimates based on 2019 data, the most recent available. “For many, the expectation of retirement doesn’t match the facts of their everyday financial lives,” said Larry Raffone, chief executive of Edelman Financial Engines. Dana and Elsie Jones hoped to become snowbirds in retirement, living half the year in Florida.
Here are the pros and cons of cashing in early — yes, early — once you hit that charmed age.
When stock prices fall, opportunities open up. That’s true whether we’re talking about a general market decline, or a slip in some individual stocks. However, it is crucial for investors to conduct due diligence and investigate the reasons behind the drop in price to ensure that they are making informed investment decisions. The key to success here is recognizing when a low-priced stock is fundamentally unsound or just facing tough trading conditions. Fortunately, Wall Street’s equity analysts a
Here's why 100K is a magic financial milestone.
Stock experts often tout the merit of taking the long-term view rather than looking for short term gains. It’s a strategy that gets the thumbs up from Morgan Stanley’s US Equity Strategy team, led by Mike Wilson. Wilson has been one of the Street’s most vocal bears for a while, but while he does not see the bear market as over just yet, he forecasts a “stronger earnings picture” by next year. A friendlier monetary policy, high inflation receding, pent-up demand in investment/capex and in specifi
(Bloomberg) — Block Inc. co-founder Jack Dorsey’s net worth was hammered after Hindenburg Research’s latest report, which alleged the payments company ignored widespread fraud. Most Read from BloombergUBS Sends Khan to Stem Credit Suisse’s Private Banker ExitsJack Dorsey’s Block Vows to Fight Back After Hindenburg Says It’s Short the StockJack Dorsey’s Wealth Tumbles $526 Million After Hindenburg ShortCredit Suisse, UBS Among Banks in DOJ Russia-Sanctions ProbeDorsey’s fortune plunged by $526 m
It can be hard to know if your retirement savings are on track, but comparing your balance to where others similar in age are can help. In particular, taking a look at the average 401(k) balance by age is a good place … Continue reading → The post The Average 401(k) Balance by Age: Are You Off the Mark? appeared first on SmartAsset Blog.
"As long as people aren't all coming in at the same time and demanding that their deposits back, you're okay, but that's exactly what's been happening," Prof. Stephan Weiler told Fortune. "So the chances of facing those unrealized losses are going up."
While social issues have dominated news coverage recently, one of the most contentious and important issues in Washington never changes – tax policy. One of former President Donald Trump's biggest victories was his 2017 tax plan that drastically reduced taxes … Continue reading → The post Are You Rich? Biden Wants to Double Your Capital Gains Taxes and Implement a Wealth Tax appeared first on SmartAsset Blog.
Sanofi's (SNY) Dupixent succeeds in a pivotal study for COPD. FDA gives CRL to AbbVie's (ABBV) Parkinson's disease therapy, ABBV-951
Novo Nordisk stock popped Friday after higher doses of its popular drug, semaglutide, led to greater weight loss in diabetes patients.
In the latest trading session, Medical Properties (MPW) closed at $7.27, marking a -1.76% move from the previous day.
Precious metals like gold and silver have been rallying lately. Let's find out which metal will rule ahead?
In my December 22 review of General Electric I doubted the strength in the stock because volume did not confirm the move. GE, nevertheless, rallied strongly. The Point and Figure charts pointed to price targets of $112 and $123 and the shares have so far stopped short of those areas.
An expert thinks the rising value of assets, like homes, could “balloon this gap even further.”